Christian Contradictions
Catholic thought and Lutheran thought are differently structured, embodying divergent conceptions of self and God. Failing to grasp the Lutheran paradigm, Catholics have wrenched Luther into an inappropriate framework. Roman/Lutheran ecumenism, culminating in the 'Joint Declaration' of 1999, attempts to reconcile incompatible systems, based on different philosophical presuppositions. Drawing on a wealth of material, both Continental and Anglo-Saxon, the author thinks through these structural questions within a historical context. But how - within a religion of revelation - can God be conceptualised as both foundational to the self and yet also as an 'other' with whom the self inter-relates? Kierkegaard is shown in a complex model to hold together strengths which historically have been exemplified by the two traditions. This is an important work in systematic theology which considers questions quite fundamental to Western religion. It should be of interest to theologians of all backgrounds and also to church historians.
- First book on Catholic/Lutheran interface subsequent to the 'Joint Declaration on Justification' in 1999
- Interesting discussion of their attempted synthesis in the work of Soren Kierkegaard
- A thorough historical and theological exploration of the incompatibility of Lutheranism and Catholicism
Reviews & endorsements
"Hampson's feel for Lutheranism is impressive, as is her discussion of Catholicism and the difference between the two traditions. As such, this book would be an important read for those interested in those traditions and in the dialogue between them." Journal of American Academy of Religion
"...[an] exceptionally readable volume...clear, convincing and challenging..." Pro Ecclesia
"This book is a rich resource for students of Reformation theology and of contemporary Lutheran-Roman Catholic relations...[a] superb contribution..." Word & World
"...[a] remarkably lucid book...vigorous and well worth one's time." Lutheran Quarterly
"[T]his work should be required for anyone seeking a deeper understanding of what lies at the heart of Catholic-Lutheran relations and dialogue." CHOICE Nov 2001
Product details
March 2004Paperback
9780521604352
336 pages
229 × 152 × 19 mm
0.517kg
3 b/w illus.
Available
Table of Contents
- Preface
- Note on the text
- Introduction
- 1. Luther's revolution
- 2. The Catholic alternative
- 3. Catholic incomprehension
- 4. Nygren's detractors
- 5. Ecumenical encounter
- 6. Dialogue with Bultmann
- 7. Kierkegaard's odyssey
- Epilogue
- Bibliography
- Index of names
- Index of subjects.