To Whom Do Children Belong?
To Whom Do Children Belong?
Most people believe that parents have rights to direct their children's education and upbringing. But why? What grounds those rights? How broad is their scope? Can we defend parental rights against those who believe we need more extensive state educational control to protect children's autonomy or prepare them for citizenship in a diverse society? Amid heated debates over issues like sexual education, diversity education and vouchers, Moschella cuts to the heart of the matter, explaining why education is primarily the responsibility of parents, not the state. Rigorously argued yet broadly accessible, the book offers a principled case for expanding school choice and granting exemptions when educational programs or regulations threaten parents' ability to raise their children in line with their values. Philosophical argument is complemented with psychological and social scientific research showing that robust parental rights' protections are crucial for the well-being of parents, children and society as a whole.
- Offers a foundational defense of the rights of parents as primary educators of their children
- Engages extensively with some of the strongest arguments for greater state authority over education put forth by Rawlsian liberal authors
- Combines scholarly depth and rigor with a readable, jargon-free style that makes the book accessible to all
Reviews & endorsements
'In one of her most persuasive passages, Moschella offers ‘[a]n Aristotelian account of the moral prerequisities for autonomomy,' in which, drawing not only on Aristotle’s Ethics but on modern child development literature as well as recent discoveries in adolescent neuroscience, she argues that genuine autonomy depends upon cultivating moral virtue, the ability to resist impulses and to act thoughtfully, weighing the consequences of one’s choices.' James R. Stoner, Jr, Claremont Review of Books
'Moschella has given us an excellent start. Her well-written and tightly argued book is an important intellectual achievement on an issue to which philosophers have not given adequate attention.' Christopher O. Tollefsen, Public Discourse
'Whatever one thinks of this critique of higher education, To Whom Do Children Belong? is a careful, balanced, and sharp work. It would pair well with Amy Guttmann’s Democratic Education in education courses. It should also challenge Rawlsians to rethink and better defend their case for mandatory liberal education.' Jon A. Shields, The Review of Politics
Product details
May 2017Paperback
9781316605004
210 pages
230 × 153 × 11 mm
0.33kg
Available
Table of Contents
- Introduction
- 1. Parent-child bonds, special obligations and parental authority
- 2. Parental rights as conscience rights
- 3. Parental rights and education for liberal democratic citizenship
- 4. Parental rights and children's autonomy
- 5. Policy implications.
