Leaving the Fight
Leaving the Fight
Surrender in warfare has determined the fate of governments, states, and nations. It has reduced powerful commanders to powerless captives and inflicted submission, degradation, and even death on common soldiers held as prisoners of war. It has also led to civilian detainees being grossly mistreated and murdered. However, surrender, prisoners of war, and detainees have rarely been addressed as general phenomena in warfare. Leaving the Fight is then an essential history of the evolution of surrender from the Middle Ages to the present day. John A. Lynn II explores the different forms taken by surrender, from the abject capitulation of armies and states to the withdrawal of forces from military interventions deemed to be unwinnable, such as in Vietnam and Afghanistan. He also considers the fates of prisoners of war and civilians detained by military forces from harsh treatment intended to intimidate foes to attempts to win over hearts and minds.
- Unique in bringing together the history of surrender, prisoners of war and civilian detainees
- Shows how the international humanitarian law of war initially emerged as an offspring of warfare and surrender in Europe
- Shows how the history of surrender can inform contemporary issues of political and military policy
Reviews & endorsements
‘John Lynn has again applied his admirable talents to an often neglected aspect of warfare, this time looking at the evolution of policies and practices dealing with prisoners and detainees. I share his admiration for the example of Major General Douglas Stone in Iraq, and also agree very much that the challenges of counterinsurgency and counterterrorism may indeed re-emerge despite contrary official expectations. This detailed analysis should be read by all future policy makers faced with the complexities of modern conflict and its impacts.’ Conrad Crane, author of Cassandra in Oz: Counterinsurgency and Future War
‘Lucidly written, deeply researched, and brilliantly argued, Leaving the Fight will be the standard work on its subject for a long time to come.’ Mark Grimsley, author of The Hard Hand of War: Union Military Policy Toward Southern Civilians, 1861–1865
‘John Lynn creates yet another paradigm for understanding war, reminding us that it is more than combat; it is also very much what comes after. With flair and countless vivid examples, Lynn assesses changes in the transition from raised weapons to raised hands, with telling consequences for peace.’ Wayne E. Lee, author of Waging War: Culture, Conflict, and Innovation in World History
‘An absorbing and thought-provoking examination of a long-neglected aspect of warfare, John Lynn's Leaving the Fight offers a cogent review of the forms of surrender and the factors that affected how soldiers and civilians were treated as prisoners and detainees. Essential for every reader of military history.’ Reina Pennington, author of Wings, Women and War
‘John Lynn provides an empirically rich, analytically and theoretically rigorous survey of the surrender of states and military units since the eleventh century. Focussing on the western experience, with particular reference to the United States, he charts the shift from prisoner exchanges to detention and captivity, coupled with the unsteady yet undeniable spread of more humane and inclusive codes of behaviour. His concluding admonition of the importance of foregoing temporary advantages that breach accepted norms is both timely and salutary.’ Peter Wilson, author of Iron and Blood: A Military History of the German-speaking Peoples since 1500
Product details
February 2025Hardback
9781107020511
346 pages
229 × 152 × 21 mm
0.671kg
Available
Table of Contents
- Preface
- 1. Introduction: Focus and Framework
- 2. The Invention of European Honorable Surrender during the Age of Chivalry
- 3. The Honors of War in Early Modern Surrender, 1650–1789
- 4. The American Civil War and its Aftermath: Confederate Surrender Transformed into Racist Victory, 1861–1877
- 5. Fighting and Ending the 'War to End War' on the Western Front, 1914–1919
- 6. Surrender in a War of Extremes, 1937–1945
- 7. Substitutes for Victory – Stalemate, Surrender, and Prisoners of War in America's Cold War Conflicts, 1950–1973
- 8. Combat, Detention Operations, and Surrender during the War on Terror, 2001–2021
- Conclusion
- Selected Relevant Works on Surrender, Prisoners of War, and Detainees
- Index.
